WHAT DOES IT MEAN TO SAY THAT WE ARE MORTAL?
When we are very young we have limited experience of death, and for most children it hits home when a grandparent dies and they sudden realize they are mortal. For household pets like cats or dogs that recognition of death may never occur and in all likelihood they live their lives without a sense of being mortal. If small animals had a sense of mortality it would be very depressing. Imagine being a mouse and knowing that your mean life expectancy is two years. Of course, length of life is relative. We don’t feel like mice because Sequoia trees live, on average, two or three thousand years. Even a 250-year-old Galapagos tortoise does not shake our sense of fulfillment in a life expectancy of 80 to 90 years. Many insects live only a matter of days or weeks and it takes a stretch of our imaginations to imagine being fulfilled in such a short life cycle. As humans we can cope with our death by assuming (as most of humanity does) that there is a life after death either in the form of a resurrected body and mind or a disembodied mind existing out there (again, for most of humanity, in some sort of heaven or hell). There is an alternative way of looking at mortality and that is stoicism. That is a philosophy I learned about reading the Enchiridion aloud to a blind high school teacher who became, without my knowing it, a private tutor. I read classical literature and “great books” to him, an hour before classes began, for several years. The Enchiridion was written by Epictetus, a handicapped Roman slave, born with a deformed leg. He taught that our life could be shaped by those events we had little or no control over (our heredity, our status at birth, wars and other calamities, or even good fortune) and those that we did have control over (our moods, how we behave toward others, and the ideals we set for ourselves). I liked that attitude and it has served me well over some 60 years of life after learning it.
Biologically, death is essential for life to evolve or even continue. If we did not die the world would be unable to provide food, room, or even oxygen for us to exist unless we gave up our desire to reproduce. Death trims the population to a sustainable size. It also fosters variations to come into being that might otherwise be repressed. Younger generations of humans do things differently than their ancestors. Their values change, their knowledge changes, their priorities differ. Older people are stuck with their habits and traditions. They often stand in the way of a youthful generation that rejects the values of the old. This is why conservative thinking tends to go with older age. Ironically the radicalism of a youthful generation is often perceived as the conservative past for the next generation. But death does not visit the old alone. It also sifts through our genetic compositions and those with inefficient immune systems or those with genetic disorders or conditions that limit their survival may fall short of our species’ life expectancy. Biologically this may make sense, but emotionally it is difficult to accept the mortality of those we love, revere, or consider models for our lives. In a way it is good that most plants and animals are unaware of death. Nature plays out its vicissitudes, as lawyers liked to note in the wills they prepared for us, and harvests through death the failures who leave fewer offspring behind. Fortunately, for humanity, we have learned to extend our life expectancy and patch up our failing organ systems, but sooner or later death wins. The machinery of life sooner or later wears out. My stoicism, so far, keeps my ideals alive.
Showing posts with label fatalism. Show all posts
Showing posts with label fatalism. Show all posts
Saturday, December 11, 2010
Sunday, November 14, 2010
LIFE LINES 32
HOW GENETIC SERVICES REDUCE FATALISM IN OUR LIVES
Before the 1940s there was little that could be done for families with children born with hereditary disorders. Nature usually solved the problem because the children with the defect, if severe, had difficulty reaching reproductive age and if they did, they might have found it difficult to find a partner with whom to have children. Parents who wanted to try again usually had no one around to give them advise on the inheritance of the trait. Things began to change after 1946 as knowledge of human heredity improved and a new field of genetic counseling began to appear in a few university hospitals. But even if the odds were made known, this did not help parents who wanted a normal child and not another child with a debilitating illness. When little of the science is known about a misfortune, people attribute their bad luck to being punished for some transgression in their past. Or they become fatalists and accept whatever happened as divine will or fate. Or they fall back on superstition and believe they were harmed by some unhappy event that occurred while pregnant or just before becoming pregnant. In the nineteenth century women giving birth to a child with port-wine birth mark on the face frequently blamed this on escaping from a fire at home or seeing a friend’s or relative’s home burn down.
But science trades these non-scientific explanations with a technical one that often makes them do a lot of soul-searching on how to apply that knowledge. This happened with the invention of prenatal diagnosis in the 1960s. Once scientists learned that we have 46 chromosomes (in 1955) and that Down syndrome had 47 (in 1959) it took less than a decade for physicians to insert a needle into the amniotic cavity of pregnant women at risk and for the cells in that fluid to be cultured, photographed and interpreted. If the cells showed trisomy-21 (the extra chromosome present in Down syndrome) women could elect to end the pregnancy and try again. About 95% of women who have faced those bad news outcomes of amniocentesis as the process is called, have chosen to abort the embryo. This is a potent moral wallop for all involved and despite all the controversy over it, most women are choosing a healthy child over one that involves a lot of medical problems. Not everyone feels ennobled by hard times whether it is poverty or raising a child with severe limitations. This is particularly true for conditions that involve a deteriorating early death of a sick child (like Tay Sachs syndrome). There are ways to shift the decision-making from a two or three month old fetus to a pre-implantation embryo in a dish, but this is much more costly to do and usually applies to those who already know they have a high probability of a repeat birth defect for their child. Genetic services provide information and options. Persons at risk have to exercise their autonomy and wrestle with their values to make a decision that best fits their situation. At least that is the prevailing model of autonomy for patients dealing with medical problems. Fifty years ago there was still a lingering desire for the state or the physician to tell the patient what to do or not do for what most of us consider a private decision. Science makes important discoveries that add to our knowledge of how different aspects of the universe, including life, works. The vast majority of humanity is not scientifically literate and until risk or tragedy strikes we think of these problems in theoretical terms (especially theological ones). When science is applied we are forced to confront our values.
Before the 1940s there was little that could be done for families with children born with hereditary disorders. Nature usually solved the problem because the children with the defect, if severe, had difficulty reaching reproductive age and if they did, they might have found it difficult to find a partner with whom to have children. Parents who wanted to try again usually had no one around to give them advise on the inheritance of the trait. Things began to change after 1946 as knowledge of human heredity improved and a new field of genetic counseling began to appear in a few university hospitals. But even if the odds were made known, this did not help parents who wanted a normal child and not another child with a debilitating illness. When little of the science is known about a misfortune, people attribute their bad luck to being punished for some transgression in their past. Or they become fatalists and accept whatever happened as divine will or fate. Or they fall back on superstition and believe they were harmed by some unhappy event that occurred while pregnant or just before becoming pregnant. In the nineteenth century women giving birth to a child with port-wine birth mark on the face frequently blamed this on escaping from a fire at home or seeing a friend’s or relative’s home burn down.
But science trades these non-scientific explanations with a technical one that often makes them do a lot of soul-searching on how to apply that knowledge. This happened with the invention of prenatal diagnosis in the 1960s. Once scientists learned that we have 46 chromosomes (in 1955) and that Down syndrome had 47 (in 1959) it took less than a decade for physicians to insert a needle into the amniotic cavity of pregnant women at risk and for the cells in that fluid to be cultured, photographed and interpreted. If the cells showed trisomy-21 (the extra chromosome present in Down syndrome) women could elect to end the pregnancy and try again. About 95% of women who have faced those bad news outcomes of amniocentesis as the process is called, have chosen to abort the embryo. This is a potent moral wallop for all involved and despite all the controversy over it, most women are choosing a healthy child over one that involves a lot of medical problems. Not everyone feels ennobled by hard times whether it is poverty or raising a child with severe limitations. This is particularly true for conditions that involve a deteriorating early death of a sick child (like Tay Sachs syndrome). There are ways to shift the decision-making from a two or three month old fetus to a pre-implantation embryo in a dish, but this is much more costly to do and usually applies to those who already know they have a high probability of a repeat birth defect for their child. Genetic services provide information and options. Persons at risk have to exercise their autonomy and wrestle with their values to make a decision that best fits their situation. At least that is the prevailing model of autonomy for patients dealing with medical problems. Fifty years ago there was still a lingering desire for the state or the physician to tell the patient what to do or not do for what most of us consider a private decision. Science makes important discoveries that add to our knowledge of how different aspects of the universe, including life, works. The vast majority of humanity is not scientifically literate and until risk or tragedy strikes we think of these problems in theoretical terms (especially theological ones). When science is applied we are forced to confront our values.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)